Comments on: Fan Meizhong, Runner Fan’s Earthquake Confessional

By: Patrick

Patrick — Sun, 30 Nov 2008 10:10:21 +0000

Life is better than any other things.No person but the teachers who saved students’ lives in the 5.12 earthquake can give a rebuke to him.Others no right …

By: Angela

Angela — Sun, 06 Jul 2008 16:37:36 +0000

While I do understand Mr. Fan Meizhong’s reaction as a selfish and senseless man, it is undeniably wrong as a ‘teacher’ and ‘civil servant’ to not at the very least warn his students to run for their lives too. As an analogy of the fundamentals of teaching, where the teacher does not provide answers to their students but rather the skills and resources to find the answers, a simple “run for your life!” may have sufficed to provide his students the ability to save themselves. It is not rocket science to anybody or at least a descent human-being that there is a certain level of social responsibility to being a ‘teacher’ / ‘civil servant’. I would imagine that this, at the very least is what Mr. Fan Meizhong would expect from his daughter’s prospective teachers.

By: sinjon

sinjon — Mon, 16 Jun 2008 08:05:59 +0000

to Anly :
it’s not sure he will lose life, but he has the duty to organize students to run away together. “lose his own life” vs “save his students’ life”, in that situation, nobody can predict it’s a problem of “choose one from two”.

to Steven Liang
1.nobody knows.
2.you can’t describe how you makelovewith you girl friend on internet, you can enjoy it in privacy.
he has the right to post, also everyone has the right to criticize him back.
3.there are laws for school to protect underage students

By: Steven Liang

Steven Liang — Mon, 16 Jun 2008 05:36:43 +0000

To all who againsts Runner Fan:

There are few very simple questions:
1). What will you do in that situation? Do you have any accident experiences. like car accident or… ..? what is ur reaction?

2). Someone said that he run away is ok that is a normally reaction in that situation, but he should not post it online afterward.Ok it sound quite reasonable. but how can you answer this question. How come in reality the thing can be done, but cant be speak out? why? And he is a human and just want to records all of things around himself. so he write the blog, but it doesnt means all of you guy should fallow him and look him like a model. right? do you have the right to write whatever u like? if you have why he dont?

3). ok lets talk about teacher. anyone who is a teacher be told in any situation have to protect his/her students until he/she die? anyone be told? if not, how come teach has to provide their life to their students? are students are more important than teacher or something else?

Im really appriciate you guys or gals who againt runner fan can give me few answers.

Thanks

By: Anly

Anly — Mon, 16 Jun 2008 02:59:34 +0000

life belong to Mr fan, who intented to get his life and give him a hero title is mean,selfish also.

By: leave

leave — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 13:35:37 +0000

A stupid question : If Fan died for his student , who can pay “responsibility, conscience, filialty” to his family ?

You have no rigtht to got “responsibility, conscience, filialty ” from others , you have no duty to give others “responsibility, conscience, filialty” also .

This is ONLY CHINA !

By: Wenxin Nie

Wenxin Nie — Mon, 09 Jun 2008 15:56:22 +0000

As I repeatedly said recently, he has no sense of responsibility, conscience, filialty, and he failed to serve a model to his students when humanity was badly needed when disaster hit.

He should not hold that teaching position any longer.

By: dairy

dairy — Wed, 04 Jun 2008 11:44:25 +0000

… a remarkable lack of conscience or responsibility - or even humanity….