Anorak | Why the case for HS2 is falling apart

Why the case for HS2 is falling apart

by | 16th, May 2013

HS2 courts ruling

HS2 is, as you know, this idea that we should build a great big train set to go through the middle of England. Politicians love train sets so all the politicians are in favour of it.

Unfortunately they’ve been lying about the numbers. Yes, lying is the correct word here. The problem is that they’ve been using 1960s figures not 00’s figures to justify it. And many people have told them that what they’re doing is wrong, misleading, lying. But they’ve carried on regardless :

The Labour MP added that transport bosses had ‘belatedly identified errors in their calculations that have wiped £12billion off the expected benefits’ and left themselves ‘no room for mistakes’.

The problem is quite simple. When you try and work out whether to build a train set of not (or indeed, embark on any other project) you do what is called a cost benefit analysis. If the costs are higher than the benefits then it’s a bad thing to do: benefits higher than costs then go for it.
When you’re talking about transport projects one of the benefits is of course that people will spend less time travelling. More time actually at places doing things and less time getting to places. Excellent.
So, what’s the value of that time saved? Standard practice is to look at what people get paid per hour. If they’re at work, or somewhere, then we assume that they’re doing work that justifies the amount they get paid. OK, it’s a little rough and ready but it is the way this is done and it’s probably the best we can do. We also assume that while they’re travelling they’re not

You have already read 1 premium article for free today
Access immediately the premium content with Multipass

Or come back tomorrow

Posted: 16th, May 2013 | In: Money Comment | Follow the Comments on our RSS feed: RSS 2.0 | TrackBack | Permalink

Contact Us Writers