Well done again to the press?! If this was a genuine call surely the fact that the whole world now knows about it gives the abductor every opportunity to move her somewhere else?

personally i don’t think they should have broadcast that yesterday, if i was that caller and genuine, I probably would be too scared to call back now

I think madeline kidnapper was not pedofil at all and antonio toscana is wrong, that her kidnapper planned kidnapping long before wrong too, but concider what he sad that madeline been choosen, I am absolut agree with him. Guys look at the right eye of madeline , on that reason and witness observation in marrakech morocco and other private arguments I build my theory that madeline been choosen by so called “GHARBI” a man who uses woodo to find treasure by the help of one geeny and that geeny would guide the GHARBI to the treasure by the help of the madeline. but I keep dreaming this. I personally know about these very old ritual but steel exit and this is the cryp: in old days people used to burry treasure deep and hard to find but if the treasure is forgotten for a long period like 100 years it become unrecoverable because a GEENY find it and hide it his way then no one kan reach it even they find it cause the geeny wil try to protect it good. Using special codes and mean woodo rituals wil let this person communicate with this geeny wich can be anything living soul special : dogs, apes, crows. So the old tale tells that some kids have special sign in the eye like the one in madeline eye and these kids wil be direct key to communicate with the geeny, the worst part will not tell it. Whatever you think, am just one human as the rest who feel so sorry for madeline and her parents specially the mother I ask God : please bring madeline home she does not deserve this whole drama. and thanks

I think it’s wicked to do this to people. Every lead should be investigated

I feel that i have to keep referring people to my earlier posts. Robert Murat left Portugal for a few days The Mirror 16th May. London-born Murat also repeatedly went in and out of the family’s holiday apartment, potentially contaminating the crime scene. He helped co-ordinate initial searches and within 24 hours of Madeleine’s disappearance had told locals she was wearing pink pyjamas.Days later, Murat is believed to have returned to the UK to visit his former wife Dawn and their daughter Sofia in Norfolk. Have the police checked Robert Murat’s travel details when he travelled out of Portugal for a few days including if he had anyone travelling with him, the possibility of a child similar to his daughter and being treated as his daughter. Could he have taken Madeline with him as his daughter if she is so like his daughter he could have got through the passport check with the child being treated as his own if his daughter is on his passport. It is a possibility.Are we sure that he went directly to England. Surely his travel details should be checked.
This reminds me of the 11 yr old Robert Houlihan from Middleton in Cork when the killer Wayne O’Donoghue helped in the search, visited Robert’s house and assured Roberts mother that he would be found. He only confessed when Roberts phone was traced and his body was found.
In relation to Sergey Malinka IF this is the same guy,(based in Portugal! then it appears he has access to sea vessels: Heaven sent gave details re Island Expeditions. http:///www.corlettmaritima.com See Malinka’s name and telephone no 00351 914168557 on Contacts on this site.
They bring groups on Expeditions from Gibralter to remote islands off the east coast of Africa in a ship originally named “Seahawk Remamed “Naomi Corlett” in 2000.

Mirror 18th May. He was also linked to a business in Lagos offering boat trips in the Mediterranean and to North Africa.
If I were the McCanns I would have a private detective travel on that ship and to the islands that it visits. If i were them I would also consider strongly visiting the ship and taking a trip on it myself. The fact that there seems to have been a suspected sighting in Morocco in the early days. She could have been brought there on that ship and possibly taken further to the Islands in west Africa.

Mirror 17th May Local reports claim Malinka disappeared from Praia da Luz at about the time Madeleine was plucked from her holiday apartment. Malinka is the third friend of Murat to be interrogated. Murat’s German girlfriend Michaela Walczuch and her Portuguese husband Luis Antonio were held.
It is strange if Malinka had nothing to hide why were his computer hard drives wiped clean when the police took it? I would be at a loss if I wiped mine clean.
Why were he and Murat in contact by phone at 11.30 PM the night Madeline went missing if they were only business contacts?
Where did Murat go when he hired the car , he could have had Madeline in the boot or God forbid her body for disposal similar to Huntley and Wayne O’Donoghue.

If these people are innocent forgive me for all the speculation but every suspicion has to be eliminated.
So concerned for Madeline and her parents.

I don’t know if Murat did anything. My gut tells me Madeleine did not wonder off or walk off a cliff. Pedophile/paedophile rings have existed and I’m sure they still do. I posted a link to information about one in Belgium.

55 minute documentary that was never “allowed” to air on our cable network……
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=866739408240639313

I’m sure there are more.

Eileen says;

It is strange if Malinka had nothing to hide why were his computer hard drives wiped clean when the police took it? I would be at a loss if I wiped mine clean.
Why were he and Murat in contact by phone at 11.30 PM the night Madeline went missing if they were only business contacts?
Where did Murat go when he hired the car , he could have had Madeline in the boot or God forbid her body for disposal similar to Huntley and Wayne O’Donoghue?

Eileen , do you seriously think that these questions have not already been asked by the Portuguese police? What do you think the answers to all these questions are?

Jan,
You have no thoughts about Robert Murat so why mention him and paedoephile rings in the same paragraph. So he looked at porn so what.

My point is that finger pointing at Robert Murat by the press has not added anything to anyone’s knowledge of what happened to Madeleine and not helped returning her to her parents.Before anyone spends to long ranting no I don’t think the McCann’s are involved. But who knows?

Paedoephile ring may exist not denying it (certainly don’t like it). But the fact is that most abuse takes place closer to home friends, relatives & parents. The reporting by the Express of a international “paedophile gang” was planning to kidnap Madeleine even watching her in UK sounds plot of a ‘B’ movie.

“The reporting by the Express of a international “paedophile gang” was planning to kidnap Madeleine even watching her in UK…”
This does sound far fetched. It definately sounds like media hype.

In most stranger abduction cases the child is snatched on impulse and opportunity. They see and they take. It’s not planned out.

JAN youre sick….I think the police should be checking on you…all pedp should be dead not only dead put the police should cut off there penis and give them a long painfull dead. not jail time just take them all out….

The sinister paedo ring story makes good copy for the tabloids but while this is a possibility, it is the one of the most unlikely scenarios. Child abduction for a couple wanting a kid is also unlikely as the 2 younger kids were left - this is significant I feel in terms of motive. I also don’t give much credability to the various sightings and phone calls as reported in the press. Research these cases, look at the typologies and profiles of the offenders, and probabilities emerge. Even without being an expert, anyone with common sense, can make an educated guess as to whats happened here.
It’s most likely to be a lone paedophile, with good local knowledge, who snatched Madeleine. The offender struck in daylight, when people were still around, thus taking quite a risk, so he (and it is a male) must have known the right time to act i.e. he had noticed Madeleine was left unattended in her appartment, and also knew where her parents were at the time. Only somebody reasonably local would have had this crucial inside knowledge ? I also think Madeleine was taken primarily because of her vulnerability, and that her parents leaving her alone was more important factor than her age etc.
The McCanns must have been watched for at least a few days or more prior to the kidnap (in my opinion). Therefore the offender is either from the resort, or had been staying in the area for a while. Child abduction is not a first offense so the culprit would probably have been into child porn, perhaps even hanging around the beach taking photos of kids etc prior to building up to a kidnap.
The level of patience and planning involved suggets an offender in his thirties, not some maniac or teenager, and so the offender would likely to be reasonably socially competent. This is an organised offender. I would also speculate, going by the offender profiles I’ve looked at, that the offender will likely live alone and own several vehicles, including a van.
There is a great deal one can pick up from this kidnap, even going by the little there has been in the press, and it all points in one direction as far as I’m concerned. I’m not saying I’m right, I’m just saying on the balance of probabilities I have formed some views on this case. Its just my personal opinion as to what I think has happened.
I also have my opinion on the suspect Robert Murat, and in particular his behaviour in the days after the kidnap - which to me is the most significant of all the evidence I’ve read about. Ask yourself - If there was a major murder investigation in your town would you 1) get involved and offer your services to the police ? 2) Would you try and hang around the crime scene and 3) quiz the journalists for info on the investigation to the point they report you to the police ? (a state informer had already reported Murat to the police a week before and he was already under surveillance).
It hurts me to say it but the outlook for Madeleine, and her family, isn’t positive. I really, really, really hope I’m wrong. However I do think the police aren’t as daft as the UK tabloids make out and that they’re on the right track.

TO YOU FRIENDLY FIRE,IM aware of otherthings around the world .but with this case of madeleine mccann had touch many heart because of the way it happened.The parent intead of eating in there room apartment went out to eat and because of them ,this poor girl is suffering.parents suppoused to protect there kids .Thats there job.i know that went something is going to happened we cant stoped it. but this could have beened prevented.i just cant not understand so many missing childrens and theres no strong law to protect this indefensive child from sickos outthere. people who harm them in anyway should have the dead penalty or be use has guineapigs for medicines has someone mentioned to me before. ( i agree anonymous .)i pray to GOD that soon we all know what really happened to this angel and pray shes not in a pedo hands.

Pete. Ian Huntley did all these things. It’s quite common apparently that the offender returns.

Innocent until proven guilty, but there are alot of things that dont stack up for Murat.

If I were Murat I would have given an interview addressing all the ‘dubious points’.

Why did he lie about the phonecalls with Malinka? Where did he go with the hire car? The poilice say they found ‘relevant sexual history’. What does that mean? For it to be relevant it must be related to a child, otherise it would not be relevant? Why did he wipe his PC before police could get hold of it? Why did he and malinka lie about their relationship?

Maybe he isn;t involved, but they’re up tp something.

JAN , i confused you with someone else went i express my self . didrent mean any harm.. but i guess its true what you said . This case of maddy had really got to me .specially since they mentioned a organize ring of pedo maybe involved .I wish i had enougth power to change the law.I mean we all could if we all stand together and do something about it. thats how some law had changed if you compare how was on youre days…right!! but anyway ilke i said before no harm dont take it personal.next time i check before i make any comment. thanks.

why dont the mccanns talk too that journalist who knows something?