Madeleine McCann: Smoke, Ribeiro Hopes And Ash
MADDY WATCH - Anorak’s at-a-glance guide to press coverage of Madeleine McCann
DAILY EXPRESS front page: “MADELEINE – McCANN FRIENDS FACE NEW PROBE. Portuguese police chief wants holiday couples interrogated”
Investigators “believe” members of the so-dubbed Tapas Nine “may” have helped the McCanns dispose of Madeleine’s body. They “could” be named as official suspects”
Page 5: “’I’m convinced Madeleine inquiry will be resolved’” – Alipio Ribeiro, Portugal’s most senior police officer, says he is “optimistic” the case will be solved
Says he: “We have an idea of what happened…In every interview there is a key moment, a click that clarifies everything and help you to reach the end”
“Kate and the ‘lost 5 minutes’” – A source says: “During the 40 minutes in which Kate left the Ocean Club restaurant and alerted the authorities about Madeleine, many things could have happened”. The possibilities, as we have read for some weeks, are endless
DAILY MIRROR page 11: “TOP MADDY COP: WE’LL CRACK IT”
Says Alipio Ribeiro: “Many similar cases have lasted longer and were resolved in the end” – Such as?
“Gerry ‘to go back’” – To Portugal? No, to work. Maybe one day
DAILY MAIL page 35: “The McCann ‘witchhunt’ – Ex yard boss condemns police pursuit of parents”
Lord Stevens is brought into the media for questioning
DAILY STAR front page: “MADDIE I KNOW THE KILLER – Top cop vows to prove his case”
Alipio Ribeiro is “convinced he knows who killed Madeleine McCann – and has vowed to prove it”. All he needs is some evidence
Page 15: “Portugal’s police chief pledges…I WILL CRACK MADDIE CASE”
THE SUN page 11: “HOW COULD POLICE DROP ASH ON CLUES? Maddie parents’ fury at evidence contamination
Kate and Gerry McCann are “horrified” that cigarette ash “could” have contaminated evidence. Says a close friend of the couple: “It is outrageous to think that messy cops could have ruined vital evidence about Maddie’s abductor”
But did they?
Suzanne McGee, a holidaymaker, says: “I saw one lady forensic person remove her mask and light a cigarette. It just looked all wrong”
Like you, we are at loss for works over this story
DAILY TELEGRAPH page 7: “McCanns’ friends to be re-interviewed by police”
Says Mr Ribeiro: What is clear is that we have the calmness to separate the story, the fantasy, from what is the police side of things”
THE TIMES page 11: “Police speak to McCann friends”
Says Mr Ribeiro: “There is a scenario that has gained strength and has a greater degree of certainty”
Gerry McCann is a “consultant cardiologist”. Kate McCann is a “part-time GP”
THE GUARDIAN and THE INDEPENDENT: No Madeleine news today
Pic: The Spine

October 23rd, 2007 at 12:48 am
First?
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:02 am
WE’re back
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:02 am
Crikey, hello Stiggy!!
2nd?
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:03 am
2 ANORAK!!!!
WTF where the hell WERE you??!!! Though Clarence had pulled some more strings!
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:06 am
Test
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:17 am
SUNDAY’S THREAD - 422 and 599 Taybie the Saxon.
Missed your post 422. I’ve written extensively on the Father Pacheco/Roman Catholic Church/secrecy of the confessional etc. issues over the past few weeks. To summarise:
1. The McCanns visting the priest within hours of Madeleine ‘disappearing’ is very strange, to put it mildly
2. For them to be given a key - apparently that night - was stranger still. It appears that Father Pabcheco’s Bishop was consulted about this
3. To get the Pope to bless a photo of Madeleine in front of the world’s press was an amazing scoop
4. The Vatican was tipped off in August that the McCanns were about to be hauled in for questioning, and treated as official suspects, and immediately wiped all references to Madeleine from their website
5. If the McCanns confessed anything to the priest, whether assault, child rape or murder, or whatever, the priest would be honour bound - nay, bound by the most solemn of oaths - to keep it a secret forever, under pain of being defrocked or even excommunicated. IMO this is indefensible; no wonder so many R.C. priests have got away with horrendous child abuse and the U.S. Catholic Church alone has paid out $2,000,000,000 in compensation to victims already
6. Father Pacheco, having gone to ground for several days in September, and apparently with a very troubled conscience, suggests to me that he knows more about the disappearance of Madeleine than he admits to knowing
7. The McCanns, though NOT ‘devout Catholics’ as was claimed, both appear to come from strongly Roman Catholic families. I suspect that Kate in particular was troubled about Madeleine needing the ‘last rites’ (or whatever mumbo jumbo is involved) on 3rd May, knowing that she was dead - and that is why she consulted the priest. Or it was part of a plan to hide the body.
Father Pacheco maybe both gave away the key and ‘holds the key’ to this case, if you see what I mean
======================================================
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:17 am
Hello qwerty people
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:20 am
Would thoroughly recommend all those interested in the Madeleine McCann ‘disappearance’ to get as much information as you can about tonight’s pretty revealing interview on Spanish TV with Kate McCann’s parents, Mr and Mrs Healy, and the Roman Catholic priest in Praia da Luz. There was a studio discussion as well with three experts/journalists. Some important deductions can be made from the material in the programme
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:20 am
Right, I can go to bed in the secure knowledge that all the lunatics are now safely back at the asylum (meant in the nicest possible way!). See you all later!
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:25 am
Tony Bennett;
Hello comrade. Yes indeed, apparently, Kate was supposed to be trying to coerce her OWN Priest, Marriage Vow blesser and Madeleine Christener, to FLY out to Portugal!!!??
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:38 am
Hoorah!!! . Back are we.Thought we had been kippered up by Clarence and Gerrykins then saw a banner that you were changing servers .
Express has waiter rant in it which is somewhat different to Mail’s abbreviated nicey nice version..careful selection going on.?
NB Mail has now got no comment section !!!!!
Damn it is bed time too. Still thank heavens Anorak is back.
October 23rd, 2007 at 1:44 am
¡I also thought that you have been censored by the C.M. Inquisition Team!!!!
What al luck you are here again… Long live Anorak
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:03 am
Hi!
Puddie and Tony Bennett
Not sure what you mean by “coerce” Spudgun? I saw that priest out in Portugal very early and speaking about the whole business. He seemed very happy to be there? Not sure what you mean? I haven’t seen the Spanish programme. How do I access it?
Take care Tony!! I know you are a very different type of Christian believer, which I respect totally, but your post smacks very definitely of anti-catholicism! The last rites are not considered “mumbo-jumbo” by huge numbers around the world. I think a little ordinary respect is called for! Sorry, but that is how I feel. I respect everyone’s religious feelings. It is a very personal thing.
GM says in his blog this evening that they spent the weekend in Liverpool and went to church with the twins. Their religion is their own affair and I don’t think the catholic, anglican, jewish, muslim or any other religion should be mocked.
It is NOT strange that they went to the priest that night. They would go for help. They rang the UK for support as well. If they had just found their daughter missing (and I don’t know what happened to her any more than anyone else does), it would be very natural to look to their pastor for help. It was natural to have wanted to pray with a pastor. They may also have thought he could influence the local police to take the matter seriously. As we know, at first the police just thought the child had wandered off. The McCanns seem to have been desperately trying every avenue to get the matter viewed more seriously and get a thorough, professional search going.
I am simply saying there is an alternative way of viewing this. There is absolutely no evidence that they ever confessed anything. They may not ever go to confession for all we know. (It’s none of our business.) It’s no longer a very widely used practice in England, I understand, especially with their age group. That priest was very pleased, from what we saw regularly on TV, to welcome them and their many visiting friends and family members to his church services. He seems to have had no crisis of conscience at all. They received communion from him regularly. He may just have been very disappointed and upset when they were made suspects.
They were certainly happy to see their own priest from England. I think you have to understand what pastors and clergy mean to different people of different faiths before you judge the significance of this.
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:04 am
Spuddie
Sorry I called you “Puddie”!!!!! Not being rude, just typing too quickly! Nice to see you all back!
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:10 am
I have just seen grandma and granfa’s interview in TV. I feel pity of them cause they look really sorrow and sad. Yet, all the journalist invited at the TV forum agrred that they relly din’t know the truh, but they also hide a lot of things.
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:11 am
Can someone post text for this story? My browser simply flits past UK Express.
Not sure why, but it does so consistently.
MADELEINE: ‘MCCANNS OR A FRIEND MUST BE TO BLAME’
UK Express, UK - 1 hour ago
By David Pilditch in the Algarve and Jane Wharton MADELEINE McCann’s disappearance could only be the fault of her parents or a family friend, it was claimed …
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:11 am
Thank heavens Anorak is back
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:18 am
Anyway (remember that I live in Madrid, so Spanish TV is my routine), all the attentandts af the live forum in TV agreed also that the C. Mitchell’s long long hand was behind the grands interview. We all think that he has told them what to say, when and how. Nobody here trust anything coming fro the Mccann team.
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:21 am
Timeline
One last thought before sleep. The waiter, if the Mail and Express are to be believed (Ha! Ha!) says that the checks were done every 20 minutes, that they were always very sensible with alcohol and very quiet etc. (so much for “swinging” “on the town” etc. etc.) and that they booked the big table at the tapas bar in order to be much nearer their apartments because they had dragged the kids with them to another restaurant in the complex on the first couple of nights but they had been very tired and needed to be put to bed earlier.
Of course, it was still wrong to do what they did, as been proved tragically to be the case, but I don’t think the “out on the lash” “couldn’t care less” attitude is quite correct either. It was made clear near the beginning of this case that what they did seemed to be common practice. Again, I never trust any newspaper but everything any of us say is only taken from the papers, TV etc. This is from the Daily Mail on 9th May.
“Madeleine’s parents ‘had left her alone before during their holiday’
Last updated at 17:41pm on 9th May 2007
The night that Madeleine McCann was abducted was not the first time that her parents had left her alone while on holiday, according to reports in Portugal.
The newspaper Correio da Manha says that the McCanns had left their children alone before during their holiday in the Algarve - a routine that, while normal at Praia da Luz, may have made it easy for her kidnapper to plan the abduction.
“Police have reconstructed the holiday routines of the McCanns and have come to the conclusion that the children were left alone on other occasions,” the newspaper says.
It reported that throughout the week the McCanns and their friends made a habit of suppers by the pool while the children - Madeleine, her twin siblings, and three other children - slept alone in the apartments. The night she was abducted, Madeleine’s parents had been checking on her roughly every half hour.
Statements to police from employees at the resort said that neither the McCanns nor other parents had demonstrated any worry about leaving the children alone. Employees also said this was normal behaviour at Praia da Luz.
The nightly routine, if observed by the kidnapper, would have made it easy to plan the kidnapping.”
Now the fact that others did it DOES NOT make it right, but it does show why they may not have felt it quite as outrageous as all that or why it “felt safe” as KM said afterwards. She had lots of messages from people who had done the same thing themselves. I think they probably felt they were just setting up their own “listening service” such as exists in a lot of similar sites and hotels. I know I would not do it myself because they were out of earshot and 20 minutes is easily long enough, obviously, for a child to wake up and be very distressed, but it’s simply important to see things as they were, without exaggeration.
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:49 am
Oh, are we are back up!!!???
October 23rd, 2007 at 2:50 am
Anyone here???
October 23rd, 2007 at 3:04 am
Kind of slow tonight.
Here’s a lot of detail captured:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madeleine_McCann
October 23rd, 2007 at 3:07 am
Here’s another UK Express article I cannot access . . . . can some one cut and post here?
KATE AND ‘THE LOST 5 MINUTES’
UK Express, UK - Oct 21, 2007
PORTUGUESE police are focusing the Madeleine investigation on five minutes when her mother cannot account for her movements, it was claimed last night. …
October 23rd, 2007 at 3:22 am
Nice to be back gang-
October 23rd, 2007 at 4:27 am
Moniker, here is the first article.
KATE AND ‘THE LOST 5 MINUTES’
PORTUGUESE police are focusing the Madeleine investigation on five minutes when her mother cannot account for her movements, it was claimed last night.
Detectives say Kate, 39, has been unable to explain where she was before she raised the alarm that her daughter had vanished on May 3. They are concerned it was 40 minutes before police were called.
It comes after independent crime experts said it would take just three minutes to hide Madeleine’s body.
Paulo Rebelo, the inquiry’s new head, is said to be planning a “minute-by-minute” reconstruction of Kate’s movements.
A source reported by Portuguese newspaper 24 Hours said: “During the 40 minutes in which Kate left the Ocean Club restaurant and alerted the authorities about Madeleine, many things could have happened.”
It added: “The body of the English girl could have been disposed of within five minutes. The police believe that a domestic accident in the apartment may have resulted in the death of little Madeleine.”
Last night it was revealed Gerry plans to return to work before Christmas. Reports said the consultant cardiologist will be given police protection when he goes back to his £75,000-a-year job at Leicester’s Glenfield Hospital.
He has been on unpaid leave since Madeleine disappeared but has said he wants to start treating heart patients again.
The McCanns’ official spokesman Clarence Mitchell said: “It is hoped that he would go back before Christmas. Whether it’s full time or starting gradually, it’s all under consideration.”
October 23rd, 2007 at 4:31 am
Oh sorry, that is the 2nd article you asked for, here is the first (Moniker).
‘MADELEINE: ‘MCCANNS OR A FRIEND MUST BE TO BLAME’
By David Pilditch in the Algarve and Jane Wharton
MADELEINE McCann’s disappearance could only be the fault of her parents or a family friend, it was claimed yesterday.
A crucial eyewitness accuses the McCanns of being irresponsible parents.
The waiter who served them on that fateful night says he cannot understand why they did not use the resort’s £10-a-night babysitting service. He even goes on to claim that he told police: “I did not think she had been taken by an abductor.
“I told them it had to be one of the family or a friend. It had to be someone close.”
Jose Batista, 45, broke almost six months of silence to give the most detailed account yet of the McCanns’ holiday and the build-up to Madeleine’s disappearance.
Mr Batista, who served the McCanns and their friends at the tapas restaurant where they were dining on the night Madeleine disappeared, says they could not have seen their apartment from their table, as they have claimed.
He also says he was surprised that they apparently made a special arrangement with staff so that they could leave their children alone on four consecutive nights to eat at the tapas bar near their apartments in the Ocean Club complex in Praia da Luz with their friends, dubbed the Tapas Nine.
“The group did check on their children regularly,” he told the Daily Express. “I know that because I often took food to the table and found one of them was not there.
“I would take it back to the kitchen to heat it up. But it was always the men who went to check, never the women.
“The only time I can remember Kate McCann leaving the table was the night that the little girl disappeared.
“It didn’t really mean anything at the time, but after all that happened I did begin to think that it was slightly strange. Why had Kate suddenly gone to check on the children that time, when she never had before?”
Mr Batista said that it was his testimony in four hours of interviews with Portuguese detectives that led to officers questioning why it was part-time GP Kate, 39, who discovered her daughter had vanished and raised the alarm.
The waiter said the McCanns and their friends had approached the resort manager to ask if they could eat at the tapas bar rather than the main restaurant as they had on the first two nights of their holiday.
The parents had complained that their children were staying out past their bedtimes when they ate at the main restaurant and were becoming tired and fractious.
He said Mark Warner managers apparently agreed and a table was set for the group at the tapas bar.
It was nearer to their apartments than the main restaurant and the group felt comfortable leaving their children unattended.
For four consecutive evenings the McCanns and their seven friends left their children alone for periods of a few minutes as they drank beer and cocktails and up to 10 bottles of wine between them.
But their decision ended in tragedy when Madeleine vanished from the McCanns’ apartment on May 3.
Mr Batista’s revelations come as Portuguese police announced that Kate and Gerry’s friends are to face new questioning.
Investigators are preparing to fly to Britain with a formal request for them to be interviewed again.
Mr Batista said it was impossible to see the McCanns’ ground-floor apartment from the restaurant despite it being less than 100 yards away.
He said: “They left their children alone. If I was in their position I certainly wouldn’t have done that.
“If they’ve got money why didn’t they get the cash together to get one nanny to look after all the children in one apartment? It is not right to say you can see their apartment from the restaurant. All you can see is the first floor upwards.”
He added: “A few days after Madeleine disappeared I gave a very detailed statement to police like all the other staff.
“I told them I did not think she had been taken by an abductor. It would not have been possible to be watching their apartment.
“During the evening the streets are quite deserted in that area. I told them it had to be one of the family or a friend. It had to be someone close.”
Last night the McCanns’ official spokesman, Clarence Mitchell, said: “We cannot discuss the events of the night of May 3. But we sincerely hope anyone who has any information will have told police.”
Responding to Mr Batista’s evidence, a close friend of the couple said: “The bottom line is that, at the time, Kate and Gerry and the others felt that they had taken adequate care to leave the children.
“Obviously, they have been proved tragically mistaken.” Of the claim that the McCanns could not see their apartment from the restaurant, the friend said: “That is a moot point.
“The holiday block could be seen, and the upper floor of the apartment where Maddie slept was in their line of vision.” On how much wine was drunk, the friend said: “I challenge anyone to remember exactly how much is drunk on an evening out with a big group of friends.
“But the point is that it was a moderate amount and nothing like the exaggeration of some reports.”
The friend said that Mr Batista’s evidence could back the McCanns’ belief that their daughter was abducted.
He said: “Kate always felt, in awful hindsight, that the group’s movements were being watched. They believe an abductor took Madeleine.”
Mr Batista said he was working in the poolside restaurant every night of the McCanns’ holiday. He said: “They were very classy people. Compared with some of the people we get, they were very polite and quiet.
They dressed well and didn’t make a mess or put their feet on chairs, anything like that.
“If they hadn’t been such a big group I probably wouldn’t have noticed them at all.”
Describing their evening routine he said: “It was always the whole group that went to dinner.
“They always ate here, always at the same time and it was always the whole group – four couples and an older woman.
“The package they were on included their dinner in the evening, and free wine to go with the meal until dessert is served.
“You often get people who keep screaming for more wine or are stupid about the rules, trying to drink as much as possible because it’s free. But the McCanns and their friends were very sensible about it.
“Sometimes they would start off with the men having a beer while the women would drink cocktails. It’s been reported that they had 14 bottles of wine a night but I was serving them and I know it was usually between eight and 10.
“Afterwards they would mostly just have a coffee or sit around chatting rather than order more alcohol.”
He added: “The group always came around 8pm, arrived within five minutes of each other and ordered their dinner, and they always left together as a group between 10.30pm and 11pm.”
Mr Batista described in detail for the first time the events that unfolded the night Madeleine disappeared. He said he was one of four waiting staff on duty during a busy period.
Mr Batista said: “I had seen them with the kids by the pool during the day. It was a normal night. They came at more or less the same time they always arrived.
“The adults were obviously enjoying some quiet time, and I realised they were taking it in turns to check on the children.
“I remember the men going off to check the children about every 20 minutes.”
But around 10pm chaos erupted after Kate returned to the table to alert the group that Madeleine had vanished. Mr Batista said: “It all became madness. We were beginning to wind down at the restaurant and I had been clearing some tables.
“I went into the kitchen for a few minutes and when I came out I saw that the McCanns’ table was empty except for the older woman. She looked scared.
“Then I heard all the shouting and screaming coming from the apartments and my colleague told me a child had gone missing.
“After that it was chaos. People were running around the resort shouting for Madeleine and we all started to help looking for her.
“My partner and I were both trying to help out. We took our cars out and searched for her. There was nothing organised.”
October 23rd, 2007 at 4:34 am
I thought like some of the others that the site had been sabotaged. It’s good to be back. I realized a day without Anorak is borrrrrrrrrrrrring.
October 23rd, 2007 at 5:21 am
3 SPUDGUN — You are back! What do think is going on? Will Kate McCann be arrested? WIll this ever end? Will the truth ever out? I’ve wached your Madeleine McCann video ten times. Please respond. Do you think the McCanns will at least be arrestetd?
October 23rd, 2007 at 5:23 am
Here’s a translation for a Oct 22 article in the Portuguese 24 Horas:
http://forums.mirror.co.uk/viewtopic.php?t=22935
Google translation of “24Horas” 22 -10
Half a million for Maddie
A small fortune. The Portuguese State, which is all of us, has paid about half a million euros to try to locate the small Madeleine McCann, disappeared on 3 May last an apartment of the Ocean Club, in Praia da Luz, Lagos, Algarve. Among police, judges and forensic experts have already spent the money equivalent to two “pools.”
The 24 made the accounts. At the beginning of the investigations and for nearly two weeks were involved in operations to search anything such as 200 agents, and investigators from the military and PJ’s GNR. Most of the Judicial investigators were deployed in Lisbon, and the National Directory and the Central Directorate of Combat the Banditisme. Only police spent in travel is something like 6,000 euros. This value must also be added the daily allowance that each police had a right to travel from Lisbon to the Algarve and that round about 50 thousand euros.
After a month of investigation the team has been reduced to about half hundred researchers and last month, for only half a dozen investigators from the PJ. Still, five months only the police cost to the state 200,000 euros to try to find Maddie.
But the costs are not confined to researchers of PJ’s military and the National Guard Republican who intervened in the case - the latter with teams cinotécnicas (dogs, search and rescue).
We must also account for the arrival of England by five policemen and their specialized teams of dogs to detect corpses. Between travel, stay and work spent by more than 100,000 euros since the girl was given as disappeared. All out of our pockets.
Further, the removal of the coordinator Gonçalo Amaral, the subsequent appointment of Paul Rebelo to lead the investigation and the strengthening of the team of inspectors of PJ was still increase the monthly costs by about 30 thousand euros.
Then there is still the staff of the Public Prosecutor of Portimão that they must treat the process, a prosecutor, a district attorney and a judge to work almost exclusively for Maddie. None of these three judges earn less than 3,000 euros per month. Putting even the Attorney-General of the Republic, which tracks the investigations hand in hand, we are talking about more than 50 thousand euros already spent in the process in just five months.
And do not think that spending is staying here. There is also the cost of the National Institute of Legal Medicine for the steps that have been requested.
Among the various examinations of DNA made under medico-legal expertise in the field of genetics and biology, which include samples of blood and saliva, samples of hair, teeth, bones or other tissues, and compared with samples from other family members to Gerry was to determine whether or not the true father of Madeleine, spent by more than 50,000 euros.
And still reach the account of the laboratory tests ordered for Birmingham, which will not be less than 200,000 euros.
The case Maddie is costing real wealth for us all. In summary, we currently pay, per day, more than five thousand euros to meet Maddie.
October 23rd, 2007 at 5:26 am
in Correio da Manha Oct. 22
http://www.correiodamanha.pt/noticia…dCanal=181&p=0
Maddie case: Missing for 172 days
Image worries McCanns
The McCanns have consulted a communication agency in Lisbon and admitted to paying an amount of 50 thousand euros per month so their image was managed in the Portuguese media. CM knows that one of the first companies that were contacted was the firm of Antonio Cunha Vaz, who presently is the image manager of the leader of PSD [political party], Luis Filipe Meneses, but even after discussing the price, and after the couple admitted to paying the amount that was discussed, the company ended up refusing.
The contact was made a few days ago, at a phase when Maddie’s parents have no representative for the media in Portugal. It also coincided with the meeting between English prime minister, Gordon Brown, and Jose Socrates [PT prime minister], during which the former solicited the Portuguese government’s commitment to contain the publicity of facts of the inquiry, namely the analyses’ results. During that approach to the Cunha Vaz Associados firm, the couple’s representatives considered the value to be high - higher than what they are paying their lawyers - but they didn’t close the door. The refusal from this firm led them to consider other possibilities, by making a wider approach to the market of communication companies. Antonio Sousa Duarte, a partner at Communicare, who works with Rogerio Alves, one of the couple’s lawyers and president of the Portuguese bar, told CM that his company “was not consulted” and that the fact that he works with this lawyer is in itself “a factor that prevents any contractual relationship with the case”.
Rogerio Alves told CM yesterday that “no communication firm was hired, nor will any be hired”. The process retreated by the couple’s lawyers, who had established contacts with some other major companies within the communication and image market.