Anorak | Jimmy Carr’s tax avoidance was never going to work – here’s why

Jimmy Carr’s tax avoidance was never going to work – here’s why

by | 21st, June 2012

YES, of course, it’s been a lovely chuckle. Jimmy Carr snarled at Barclay’s for dodging taxes and then is revealed as someone who has been doing his best to do the same. Yes, I know, I know, Polly Tonybee’s kids went to private school, as did Alan Rusbridger’s I think; Ken Livingstone still hasn’t managed to provide a full tax accounting even though the election’s well over. Richard Murphy, the nationally known tax expert, reportedly, has been shown to have used exactly the schemes that he denounced as “tax abuse” in a report for the TUC.

It’s all very amusing really, isn’t it? But the question I have about all of this is, well, why are they so damn bad at dodging taxes? Take Carr for example: unless he’s about to do something very strange indeed then he’s not actually been able to dodge any tax. He’s delayed having to pay it, yes, this is true, but not actually dodged it.

The essential nut of the scheme was that instead of being paid the money he earns it all goes off to Jersey and he gets minimum wage or the like. Then the rest of the cash is lent to him instead of paid to him. As it’s a loan which he has to pay back there’s no tax on it.

Except, well, HMRC says that in this case you have to

You have already read 1 premium article for free today
Access immediately the premium content with Multipass

Or come back tomorrow

Posted: 21st, June 2012 | In: Money Comment | Follow the Comments on our RSS feed: RSS 2.0 | TrackBack | Permalink